1
Friday
July 2022
10:22 AM IST
News Headlines
Eknath Shinde is Maharashtra Chief Minister, Devendra Fadnavis his deputy        Uddhav Thackeray steps down as Maharashtra CM after SC refuses to stay floor test        BJP takes stock of situation as rebel Shiv Sena MLAs consolidate position to topple MVA govt        Return and talk to me: Uddhav Thackeray to rebel MLAs camping in Guwahati        Defamation case: Kangana Ranaut to appear before Mumbai court on July 4        England will come out with same mindset against India: Ben Stokes        CHANGE IN BLOOD GROUP-IS IT POSSIBLE?        Biden, G-7 leaders huddle on energy, inflation, Ukraine war        Russia strikes Kyiv as troops consolidate gains in the east        FinMin asks banks to explore fintech partnership, co-lending opportunities        Rohit Sharma can be relieved as captain from T20s: Sehwag        Former goalkeeper Petr Cech leaving Chelsea advisory role        ED summons Shiv Sena MP Sanjay Raut on Tuesday        Assam flood situation improving, 22 lakh affected        Keep the momentum intact till 2024 Lok Sabha election: Mayawati        SC grants relief to rebel Sena MLAs, no decision be taken on their disqualification till July 11        Italy pips US men to relay gold in swimming worlds finale        After 5 months, ONGC finally gets a director on HPCL board        FinMin asks banks to explore fintech partnership, co-lending opportunities        Biden, G-7 leaders huddle on energy, inflation, Ukraine war        
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | About Deepika 
International News
Ukraine: Russian opposition to the invasion is giving Putin cause for alarm
 
London, Mar 5 (The Conversation) Vladimir Putin's military aggression against Ukraine is meeting more opposition from Ukrainians than he expected. The Russian president also saw widespread condemnation of his military's aggression in Ukraine at the UN General Assembly. But the opposition Putin faces domestically in Russia is also likely giving him cause for alarm.

There are clear reasons, however, to be sceptical of claims that Putin will soon be deposed in a palace coup or that the existing elite could be removed by mass protests.

There are three broad categories of Russians who have voiced their opposition to the war, albeit in different ways. It helps to visualise these as three concentric circles, starting from the largest and closing in.

Anti-war street protests attended by regular citizens have swept the country. Within the first week of Russia's full-scale military invasion of Ukraine, at least 7,669 people were detained by police at anti-war protests across Russia according to OVD-Info, a Russian human rights organisation. Those detained include people all the way from primary school children to an elderly pensioner in St Petersburg.

Jailed opposition figure Alexei Navalny has called for daily anti-war protests in and outside Russia, referring to Putin as an insane tsar .



Cultural elite and the intelligentsia

Portions of the intellectual and cultural elite have also voiced their opposition to war from TV celebrities to sportspeople and scientists. Beyond individual statements, a flurry of open letters have been signed, including by 44 of the country's top chess players and by academics.

There are already cases, though, of signatories facing negative consequences, including losing their jobs. As well as the detentions at protests, this serves as a clear reminder of the bravery of those publicly opposing the war.



Economic and political elite

What about important economic actors? With the enormous fortunes that stand to be lost because of the west's unprecedented sanctions on Russia, it is plausible that they might speak out.

Some already have. A few of Russia's wealthiest people for example, the oligarchs Mikhail Fridman and Oleg Deripaska have called for peace. One of the country's largest oil companies, Lukoil, has also called for an end to the war in Ukraine.

But there is clear caution. Calling for peace is not the same as directly criticising Putin, as Fridman has acknowledged.

Some public dissent has also been shown already by minor political officials: for instance, a Russian adviser to the World Bank and a Russian delegate at a UN climate conference.

What about people higher up the political food chain? Today's Kremlinology has begun to resemble that of the Soviet era, where the opacity of politics forced western analysts to scrutinise material like photographs of official events to glean insights into intra-elite dynamics.

In similar fashion, people are now trying to read the body language of senior officials during meetings with Putin for signs of disquiet. One notable example relates to an image of Elvira Nabiullina, the head of Russia's Central Bank, captured looking glum with her arms crossed and eyes down at the opposite end to Putin of a comically long table.

So far, however, there are no signs of significant cracks at the top. And that's no surprise Putin has surrounded himself with hyper-loyalists, the inner circle of which share his impression of a west intent on undermining Russia and his rule. Even if members of the broader political elite are deeply shocked by or disagree with Russia's assault on Ukraine, the costs of voicing dissent or trying to exit the system are overwhelmingly high. For the moment, at least.



The true depth and breadth of opposition



It's very difficult to measure the true extent of opposition to the war and to Putin personally across these three groups, as well as to work out how this might change over time.

The Russian president's press secretary, Dmitry Peskov, has said that the level of support for the president, for his decisions, and his actions is very, very high . According to the Kremlin-friendly VTsIOM polling agency, 68% of Russians support Russia's activities in Ukraine, with another Kremlin-aligned agency, FOM, reporting that 71% of Russians trust in Putin following the start of Russia's military operation, up from 60% just before the invasion.

How can this be? Russian state media continues to portray a very different reality to the coverage in western media. Rather than a full-scale assault, the narrative is of a special operation to protect ethnic Russians in the so-called republics of Donetsk and Luhansk from genocide being carried out by Ukraine's neo-Nazi government.

Words like invasion and war are banned in Russian media. Independent outlets have been blocked or shut down. And Russians face the prospect of harsh punishment for challenging the state's line on the conflict.



A bleak outlook

The degree of opposition going forward depends on a number of factors, including the Russian military's ability to subdue Ukrainian forces. The scale of economic hardship in Russia will also influence public opinion. But a lot will also depend on the Russian state's capacity and willingness to repress dissent at home and continue to control the narrative. We'll see economic problems and the deaths of Russian soldiers continue to be blamed by the Kremlin on the west.

Putin has staked his survival on this. And we've seen what he is capable of doing to critical voices: the incarceration of Navalny and the poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko in 2006 being just two examples. Given the steps that have already been taken to respond to domestic opposition, it is likely that in the short term, at least we will see a doubling down of repression, including to prevent any cascade of dissent that might shake the very foundations of the regime.


Biden, G-7 leaders huddle on energy, inflation, Ukraine war
Russia strikes Kyiv as troops consolidate gains in the east
Biden, G-7 leaders huddle on energy, inflation, Ukraine war
Russia strikes Kyiv as troops consolidate gains in the east
China city mayor apologises over COVID-19 lockdown response
2 members of Iran's Revolutionary Guard die amid tensions
Britain's Queen becomes world's second-longest reigning monarch
Ukraine: Russia said to be using more deadly weapons in war
US stresses allied cooperation in face of N Korea threats
Russia draws closer to capture of Ukraine's Donbas region
NASA to launch 3 rockets from private Australian space port
Boris Johnson wins no-confidence' vote: but the margin will make him nervous
Sri Lanka PM Wickremesinghe hints at opting for fuel rationing amid economic crisis
President Biden, First Lady visit site of devastating school shooting in Texas
Putin blames West for food, energy crises
US to hold Russia accountable for crimes
Shanghai starts coming back to life as COVID lockdown eases
UK PM Boris Johnson forced to explain actions in fresh partygate row
add add Shanghai moves toward ending 2-month COVID-19 lockdown
Last body recovered from Tara Air plane crash site: Nepal Army
ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
RRR can hit theatres on Holi
 Mumbai, SS Rajamouli's much-anticipated "RRR" is ready to hit threatres if Covid surge ends and full  
King Khan returns to Insta after months of silence
Celebrity couple Dhanush-Aishwarya Rajinikanth part ways
Preity Zinta enjoys "Ghar ki Kheti"
KERALA NEWS
Swapna Suresh appears before ED
 Kochi: Key accused in the Kerala gold smuggling case, Swapna Suresh, appeared before the Kochi unit
Kerala HC to hear Swapna Suresh’s plea on June 21
Pinarayi Vijayan Faces Youth Congress Protest Aboard Aircraft
Kerala: CPM workers attack Congress office after CM shown black flag in flight
NATIONAL NEWS
Return and talk to me: Uddhav Thackeray to rebel MLAs camping in Guwahati
 Mumbai, Jun 28 (PTI) Shiv Sena president Uddhav Thackeray on Tuesday appealed rebel MLAs of his part
Defamation case: Kangana Ranaut to appear before Mumbai court on July 4
ED summons Shiv Sena MP Sanjay Raut on Tuesday
Assam flood situation improving, 22 lakh affected
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2021 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.