21
Thursday
March 2019
9:10 PM IST
News Headlines
Soldier killed as Pak army violates ceasefire along LoC in Rajouri        SAFF Women C''ship: Indian women thrash Bangladesh 4-0, will face Nepal in finals        Theresa May seeks Brexit Day delay, EU demands new vote        Nirav Modi arrested in UK; court remands him in custody till March 29        Mayawati won''t contest LS polls, but says still possible to become PM        Samjhauta blast case: Swami Aseemanand, 3 others acquitted        Not playing is not the solution: Ganguly on workload management        IPL schedule: KKR gets relief, to play all home matches at Eden        Rupee pauses after 6-day rally, slips 43 paise against US dollar        Jaitley dubs '108 purported economists' as compulsive contrarians        Sack 3 ministers in Imran Khan's govt for supporting banned outfits: Bilawal        Pak court mulls options for recording Musharraf's statement in treason case        HC takes note of 'dearth' of special education teachers in Delhi schools        Cong-JDS to campaign jointly, vow to reduce BJP to single        Mamata lashes out at BJP for questioning her religion        Jet pilots threaten to stop flying from Apr 1, set Mar 31 deadline on bailout, salaries        Congress will restore special category status to Arunachal and other NE states: Rahul        We think about the future: Sasi Tharoor        No riots in UP since BJP came to power: Adityanath        Congress finally picks Muraleedharan for Vadakara        
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | Health   | About Deepika 
Kerala News
Supreme Court sees no wrongdoing in Rafale deal, rules out probe
 
(New Delhi, Dec 14, 2018):Vindicating the position of the central government and Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the Supreme Court on Friday said there was “no occasion to really doubt” the procurement process of 36 Rafale fighter jets “even if minor deviations have occurred”.

The Congress had accused Modi of malfeasance in the deal. The three-judge Bench led by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi said after perusing the material provided by the government and having interacted with Air Force officers, the court did not see any reason as to why it should intervene in “the sensitive issue of the purchase of 36 defence aircraft by the Indian government”.

The Bench said the court lacked the technical expertise to examine issues such as pricing and the choice of offset partners. Justice Gogoi cited national security concerns to say it could not step into issues such as defence contracts and procurements.

“Perceptions of individuals cannot be the basis for a fishing and roving enquiry by this court, especially in such matters. We, thus, dismiss all the writ petitions,” the Bench said.

Apart from advocate M L Sharma, who had moved the first plea in the case, former BJP ministers Yashwant Sinha and Arun Shourie, and senior advocate Prashant Bhushan had filed separate pleas, in which they had petitioned the court to order a court-monitored probe into the decision-making process of the government while buying the jets, the alleged difference in prices in the new deal as compared to the old deal signed by the United Progressive Alliance government, and the choice of the Indian offset partner.

On October 10, the court had asked the government to place before it the details of the steps taken while arriving at the decision to buy the 36 fighter jets. It had made clear that the details being sought were only to ensure the correctness of the decision-making process.

The court had said it would not go into the issue of pricing or matters related to the technical stability of the fighter jets.

The apex court on Friday reiterated its earlier stand and said it could not sit in judgment of the wisdom of deciding to purchase 36 aircraft in place of 126.

“We cannot possibly compel the government to go in for purchasing 126 aircraft,” the court said.

The three judges steered clear of the issue of escalation in the cost of the fighter jets and said though they were inclined to go into the details of pricing, it was not the job of the court to carry out a comparison of pricing details.

The court accepted the government’s claim that there was a commercial advantage in the purchase of 36 Rafale aircraft as compared to 126 owing to better terms of maintenance and weaponry.

It did not venture into the issue of choosing an offset partner for the deal, which has been perhaps the biggest sparring issue for the government and the opposition, either, and said it did not find substantial material to show that the government showed commercial favours to any party.

Though Reliance Aerostructure was formed recently, the court did not go into the details of commercial agreements between the Anil Ambani-led Anil Dhirbubhai Ambani Group and Dassault, and said it was “neither appropriate nor within the experience of this court to step into this arena of what is technically feasible or not”.


We think about the future: Sasi Tharoor
No riots in UP since BJP came to power: Adityanath
Congress finally picks Muraleedharan for Vadakara
I always stand for the principles and ethics I believe in: Sasi Tharoor MP
Seven year old boy dies of West Nile Virus
LS elections in left ruled Kerala to go Green
P J Joseph meets Cong leaders over Kottayam LS seat
Man arrested for harassing woman pilot in Thiruvananthapuram
Thunderbolt commandos combat with Maoists during combing operations in Wayanad
INS Sharda rescued five fishermen
Dubai Police team visits Kerala Police headquarters
Kerala State Film Awards 2019 announced: Jayasurya, Soubin, Nimisha, Kanthan: The Lover of Color bags top honours
Fire breaks out in a QRS showroom
Flash Hartal in Kerala: Stray incidents of violence reported
Thousands bid emotional farewell to CRPF jawan in Kerala
Religious practices should be respected: Smriti Irani
Malayali soldier among the CRPF men killed in terrorist attack
Government to take action against who leaves office after punching
Women's Commission files case against MLA S Rajendran
Kathakali artist Chavara Parukkutty passes away
ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
Gwyneth Paltrow hasn't quit acting
 Los Angeles: Gwyneth Paltrow says she has not bid adieu to acting. The actor, who was last seen in "  
Shooting complete for 'The Sky Is Pink'
Maisie Williams to star in thriller 'The Owners'
Swara Bhasker turning producer
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
Theresa May seeks Brexit Day delay, EU demands new vote
 London: British Prime Minister Theresa May wrote to the European Council on Wednesday seeking a "sho
Sack 3 ministers in Imran Khan's govt for supporting banned outfits: Bilawal
Pak court mulls options for recording Musharraf's statement in treason case
Musharraf admitted to Dubai hospital after reaction from rare disease : Party
NATIONAL NEWS
Mayawati won''t contest LS polls, but says still possible to become PM
 Lucknow/New Delhi, Mar 20 (PTI) BSP chief Mayawati Wednesday announced she will not contest the upco
Samjhauta blast case: Swami Aseemanand, 3 others acquitted
HC takes note of 'dearth' of special education teachers in Delhi schools
Cong-JDS to campaign jointly, vow to reduce BJP to single
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2019 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.