6
Friday
December 2019
7:42 PM IST
News Headlines
Mumbai, Kerala play out 1-1 draw in Hero ISL        Have some thoughts for T20 World Cup, will discuss with Kohli and Shastri: Ganguly        RBI keep repo rate unchanged        Saudi Aramco raises USD 25.6 bn in largest-ever IPO        Iran informs UN about determination to continue Ballistic Missile Program        Next Hearings in Trump Impeachment Process Scheduled on Monday - House Judiciary Committee        Burundi: 38 killed in landslide in Cibitoke        Naidu condemns attack on Unnao rape survivor        1984 riots: Javadekar slams Manmohan Singh, says if Rao was so bad, why did you become FM under him?        The Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill 2019 returned to Lok Sabha        Govt clueless on how to tackle economic slowdown, FM statement on onion shows their mindset: Chidambaram        Rajya Sabha passes bill to amend SPG Act, Shah rejects charge of political vendetta, Cong stages walkout        Kerala shocked by plight of poor mother, six children        Rupee ends steady ahead of RBI policy outcome        HC asks Ker govt to take control of Church        Not difficult working with Sena compared to BJP: Pawar        India conducts fresh night trial of Prithvi-2 missile        Three directors of PMC Bank arrested        Quinta Brunson to star in HBO Max's single-camera comedy        David Kerr to helm 'Joy To The World'        
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | Health   | About Deepika 
Main News
Karnataka political crisis: SC to deliver order Wednesday on pleas of rebel MLAs
 
New Delhi: The Supreme Court will deliver on Wednesday its crucial order on pleas of 15 rebel Congress-JD (S) MLAs seeking a direction for Karnataka Assembly Speaker K R Ramesh Kumar to accept their resignations, which may seal the fate of 14-month-old H D Kumaraswamy government. The apex court reserved its order after high-voltage arguments in which Kumaraswamy and the Speaker questioned its jurisdiction on entertaining the rebel MLAs, who alleged that they are being forced to act in a particular manner so as to save the coalition government that has lost majority.

Kumaraswamy and Kumar contended that the court cannot enter into the Speaker''s domain by asking him first to decide on the resignations of these MLAs and thereafter the applications seeking their disqualification. However, a bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi said it was not restraining the Speaker from deciding the disqualification but was only asking him to ascertain whether they voluntarily resigned. The bench, also comprising Justices Deepak Gupta and Aniruddha Bose, also said that the apex court had given a "very high status" to the Speaker while interpreting the anti-defection law decades ago and "probably that needs a re-look after so many years".

The bench said there are rival submissions on the issue of resignation and disqualification of MLAs and "we will do the required balancing". The court also questioned the contentions of the Speaker that the issue of disqualification has to be decided first by asking him what was he doing till July 10 when the MLAs had resigned on July 6 itself. "On July 6, they (rebel MLAs) say they had given their resignations. The Speaker did not do anything until the Supreme Court''s order (of July 11)," the bench said. "What is the scope of the pending disqualification?" it added. "Pursuant to the court''s order, they appeared physically before the Speaker.

Then why he (Speaker) did not decide it? He (Speaker) is saying that he will take time in deciding this. What does he mean by this?," the bench asked. Senior advocate Rajeev Dhavan, appearing for Kumaraswamy, said that these rebel MLAs are "hunting in a pack" and the Speaker cannot "turn a blind eye" to it since their motive is to bring down the government. "This is not the Speaker versus the court. This is between the Chief Minister and somebody who wants to become the Chief Minister and bring down this government," he said, while urging the court to vacate its two interim orders asking the Speaker to decide the resignations, and maintain a status quo. Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for rebel MLAs, said the Speaker is acting in a "partisan" and "mala fide" manner by not accepting their resignations and he has "frustrated" the fundamental rights of these lawmakers to resign.

He said as per constitutional rules, Speaker has to take an "immediate" decision on resignations and by not doing this, the Speaker is "flouting the rules". "Here is a government which has lost majority in the House and here is a Speaker who wants to prop this government," Rohatgi said, adding that resignation is different from disqualifications proceedings, which is akin to a time taking "mini-trial". He said the whole design not to accept resignations and keep the disqualification issue pending is for making the ruling coalition issue a whip to their MLAs to act in a particular manner when the confidence motion is put to vote on July 18 as any contrary action would invite disqualification.

Senior advocate A M Singhvi, appearing for the Speaker, said disqualification pleas against the MLAs were filed prior to their resignations on July 11 when they physically appeared before Speaker. "It is a common ground that 11 out of these 15 MLAs have handed over their resignations physically to the Speaker on July 11," he said, adding that, "resignation cannot be a ground to frustrate the disqualification proceedings". However, when Singhvi was making the submissions that the MLAs had earlier not made their physical appearance before the Speaker, the bench asked, "What stopped you (Speaker) from taking the decision when these MLAs physically appeared before you on July 11 after this court passed the order".

"What stopped you (Speaker) to say whether the resignations were voluntary or not?", the bench asked the senior advocate, who said the "Speaker was taking a holistic view before deciding the resignations". Singhvi said that there is a one-page affidavit of the Speaker seeking modification of its interim order by which he was asked to maintain status quo so that he can decide the issue of resignation of these MLAs. While he was making this submissions, the bench said, "Very well. You decide the resignation at the earliest and then decide the disqualification."

Singhvi said the apex court does not have such jurisdiction to ask the Speaker to act in a particular manner or to decide the issue of resignation in a time-bound manner. He also submitted that the Speaker can take decision on both the issues -- disqualification and resignation -- if asked by Wednesday. The day''s hearing concluded after Rohatgi asked the bench to pass a direction to continue with its interim order directing the Speaker to maintain status quo on the issue of resignations and disqualification of the MLAs. He also asked the bench that if the House assembles for business the 15 rebel MLAs be exempted from appearing on the basis of the whip of the ruling coalition.


Govt clueless on how to tackle economic slowdown, FM statement on onion shows their mindset: Chidambaram
Rajya Sabha passes bill to amend SPG Act, Shah rejects charge of political vendetta, Cong stages walkout
HC asks Ker govt to take control of Church
Not difficult working with Sena compared to BJP: Pawar
Sacked from Ayodhya case, says Muslim parties' lawyer Rajeev Dhavan
Shah sets 2024 deadline for NRC, says all infiltrators to be expelled by then
Mobile call, internet to become costlier by up to 50 pc from Dec 3
Uddhav Thackeray-led govt passes floor test amid BJP boycott
Poet Akkitham bags ''Jnanpith Award'' in Literature
Uddhav Thackeray sworn in 18th chief minister of Maharashtra
Still with NCP; Uddhav will decide on induction: Ajit Pawar
Maha drama: Fadnavis makes way for Sena-NCP-Cong combine
SC order on Maharashtra govt formation on Tuesday morning
M''rashtra:SC asks Centre to place letters of Guv & Fadnavis; rival alliances claim majority
Maha political impasse ends with surprise; Fadnavis CM, NCP''s Ajit Pawar his deputy
Opposition accuses BJP of receiving money from firm under probe for ''terror funding''
Students, parents stage protest over death of girl due to snakebite in classroom
Three Rafale jets handed over to IAF by France: Govt
Helmets must for two-wheeler riders, pillions from Dec 1 : HC
Winter Session starts on stormy note; Opposition uproar in LS
KERALA NEWS
Kerala shocked by plight of poor mother, six children
 Thiruvananthapuram: This hapless mother was unable to find food to fill the little stomach of her ch  
Kerala: Youth hurled down by Policeman during vehicle checking, seriously injured
Kerala High Court takes suo moto case against lawyers protested against magistrate
School girl killed of snakebite: Separate demonstrations by YC, SFI turns violent, police resorts to lathicharge
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
Iran informs UN about determination to continue Ballistic Missile Program
 Tehran: Iran informed UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres about plans to develop its ballistic mis
Next Hearings in Trump Impeachment Process Scheduled on Monday - House Judiciary Committee
Burundi: 38 killed in landslide in Cibitoke
Putin signs off law to label journalists as foreign agents
NATIONAL NEWS
Naidu condemns attack on Unnao rape survivor
 New Delhi: Rajya Sabha chairman and Vice-President Venkaiah Naidu condemned the incident in which a
1984 riots: Javadekar slams Manmohan Singh, says if Rao was so bad, why did you become FM under him?
The Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill 2019 returned to Lok Sabha
India conducts fresh night trial of Prithvi-2 missile
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2019 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.