21
Sunday
July 2019
12:28 PM IST
News Headlines
Priyanka ends her ''dharna'' in Chunar, Cong to pay Rs 10 lakh to victims'' kin        Sheila Dikshit passes away        Western allies back UK over tanker seizure        Shiva Thapa becomes India''s first gold-medallist in Kazakhstan President''s Cup        Three beaten to death in Bihar over attempted buffalo theft        Priyanka detained on way to Sonbhadra, says prepared to go to jail        Heavy rains continue in Kerala        Indian-American adoptive father of Sherin Mathews challenges life term, seeks new trial        PM Khan to travel to US on commercial flight        Trump reaffirms Iranian drone destroyed, Tehran denies        Sindhu tames old rival Okuhara to enter semis of Indonesia Open        Dhoni has no immediate plans to retire, says longtime friend Arun Pandey        Team India squad for Windies Tour to be announced on July 21        India asks Pak to implement ICJ verdict on Jadhav immediately; Imran says shall proceed as per law        Trust vote; Karna assembly adjourned amid din; Guv directs CM to prove majority by Friday 1.30 pm        IT dept attaches assets of Mayawati''s brother, BSP blames BJP govt        33 dead in suspected arson attack on Japan animation studio        Former Pak PM Abbasi arrested over corruption case        Iran Guards say they have seized a ''foreign tanker''        Bayliss replaces Moody as Sunrisers head coach        
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | Health   | About Deepika 
National News
Morphed image of WB CM: SC says arrest of activist prima facie arbitrary
 
New Delhi: The Supreme Court Wednesday termed as "prima facie arbitrary" the arrest of BJP's youth wing leader for allegedly posting morphed image of Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on social media and pulled up the West Bengal government for the delay in releasing her.

A vacation bench comprising justices Indira Banerjee and Sanjiv Khanna was informed by the counsel of activist Priyanka Sharma's brother that she was not released from jail on Tuesday despite the apex court's order granting her bail and ordering her immediate release.

However, the counsel for West Bengal government informed the bench that she has been released from jail at 9:40 am today.

"Why 9:40 am today? The order was passed in your presence," the bench told the state counsel.

When the state's counsel referred to the jail manual, the bench shot back, "Jail manual can't have precedence over an order of the Supreme Court."

"No. This is not done. First of all the arrest was prima facie arbitrary," the bench said.

Senior advocate Neeraj Kishan Kaul, appearing for Priyanka's brother Rajib Sharma who filed the plea in the apex court, told the bench that despite the apex court's Tuesday order granting her bail she had to spend another night behind the bars.

Kaul told the bench that jail authorities Tuesday told them that they have to either bring certified copies of the apex court's order or approach the court of the chief judicial magistrate concerned for her release.

"If she is not released, the consequences will follow," the bench said and warned it will issue contempt to officials concerned if Sharma was not released from jail immediately.

"She should be released from jail within half an hour," the bench said.

The bench asked Kaul to get instructions whether she has been released from jail or not.

After a few minutes Kaul informed the bench that Sharma has been released from jail today.

Kaul told the court that they have moved a separate application, in which they have said that though the closure report in the case was filed in the trial court on May 13, the apex court was not informed during yesterday's hearing.

"If the Supreme Court was informed yesterday that the closure report has been filed in the trial court, then the apex court might not have asked her to apologise," Kaul said.

The apex court had Tuesday granted bail to Sharma and asked to apologise for posting the morphed image of Banerjee.

During the hearing on Wednesday, Kaul said the counsel for West Bengal was present in the apex court during yesterday's hearing but did not apprise the court about the closure report.

"You know very well what happens to a counsel appearing for the state," the bench observed.

To this Kaul said, "I am not on the counsel but I am on the conduct of the state."

However, the bench told Kaul to check up whether Sharma has been released from jail or not.

"If she is not released, we will issue contempt," the bench said.

However, Kaul said when the apex court had yesterday said that Priyanka should be released forthwith, why jail authorities did not release her.

"Does West Bengal state or the police have right to detain her even for a minute after the Supreme Court's order," Kaul asked.

He told the bench that their application be listed for hearing next week.

However, the bench said since Sharma has been released there was no urgency and the application will be heard in July after the summer vacation.

After taking instructions, Kaul told the bench that Sharma has been released from jail but jail authorities "forced" her to give an apology before being released from the prison.

Sharma was arrested on May 10 by the police under section 500 (defamation) of the IPC and under other provisions of the Information Technology Act on a complaint of a local Trinamool Congress leader Vibhas Hazra.

She was sent to 14-day judicial custody by a trial court there.

The apex court, which initially said Sharma's apology will be a bail condition, later clarified that it will not be a condition for bail but she should apologise for sharing the post at the time of her release.

The court had also sought response from West Bengal government on whether a person can be arrested for sharing a post or meme on social media and posted the matter for further hearing after the summer vacation.

On Monday, Kaul had mentioned the matter in the top court for urgent hearing, saying Sharma was forced to move the apex court as there was a complete strike in local courts till May 14 in Howrah and moreover, she had been remanded in 14-day judicial custody by a Howrah court on May 11.

Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) entails punishment for defamation with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both.

Sharma had allegedly shared on Facebook the photo in which Banerjee's face has been photo-shopped on to actor Priyanka Chopra's picture from the MET Gala event in New York.

Her arrest was followed by protests from the BJP and other social media users.


Priyanka ends her ''dharna'' in Chunar, Cong to pay Rs 10 lakh to victims'' kin
Three beaten to death in Bihar over attempted buffalo theft
Priyanka detained on way to Sonbhadra, says prepared to go to jail
India asks Pak to implement ICJ verdict on Jadhav immediately; Imran says shall proceed as per law
IT dept attaches assets of Mayawati''s brother, BSP blames BJP govt
Karnataka crisis: Cong leaders speak in divergent voices on SC verdict
MLAS Karnataka crisis: SC says rebel MLAs not to be compelled to take part in Assembly proceedings
189 new rail lines under construction: govt
Former PM Chandra Shekhar''s son Neeraj Shekhar joins BJP
11 killed, over 40 feared trapped as Mumbai building collapses
Civic body to impose water cuts in Nagpur from Wed
Chandrakant Patil new chief of Maharashtra BJP
Karnataka crisis: SC agrees to hear plea of 5 more rebel MLAs on Tuesday
Demand to raise royalty on coal in Rajya Sabha
Death toll in Himachal building collapse climbs to 13
Man seriously injured as mobile explodes while speaking
Karnataka crisis: SC agrees to hear plea of 5 more rebel MLAs on Tuesday
Nadda rejects horse-trading charge; says new political culture
GFP meet at Parrikar memorial violated its sanctity: Goa BJP
Navjot Singh Sidhu resigns as Punjab Cabinet Minister
ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
Lata Mangeshkar asks MS Dhoni to not retire
 New Delhi: The Nightingale of Bollywood has requested Mahendra Singh Dhoni to not consider retiremen  
Omar Abdullah, Shah-Faesal support Zaira's decision to quit acting, wish her luck
Daisy Ridley will never return to social media
'Bond 25' reveals first look from Jamaica sets
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
Western allies back UK over tanker seizure
 Paris: Iran''s seizure of a UK-flagged tanker in the Strait of Hormuz has further heightened tension
Indian-American adoptive father of Sherin Mathews challenges life term, seeks new trial
PM Khan to travel to US on commercial flight
Trump reaffirms Iranian drone destroyed, Tehran denies
KERALA NEWS
HC pulls up Kerala govt over Munnar encroachments
 Kochi: The Kerala High Court Wednesday pulled up the state government over the issue of alleged encr
Student Stabbed at University College: SFI leaders have gone absconding
Ker CM takes a dig at Congress MLAs on quitting spree
Special Additional Sessions court permits Dileep to travel abroad
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2019 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.