24
Saturday
August 2019
9:50 AM IST
News Headlines
I find nets claustrophobic, prefer centre wicket for match simulation: Kohli        Rahane's 81 only saving grace in India 203 for 6 on day 1        No more dessert names, Google to officially call new OS 'Android 10'        Sensex, Nifty rebound on hopes of FPI tax rollback        Despite tensions, Pak stands ready to open Kartarpur Corridor: Qureshi        Two Govt hospitals in Pak deny specialised ambulance facility to Sharif        UN, France raise concern over Amazon wildfires 'crisis'        INX Media: SC grants interim protection to Chidambaram in ED case; no relief in CBI matter        Always said demonising Modi wrong: Singhvi        Alert in Tamil Nadu after intel of Lashkar terrorists' intrusion        FM proposes measures to enhance fund flows for infra, housing projs        FATF Asia-Pacific Group puts Pakistan in terror 'blacklist': Officials        Vivek Oberoi to star in film on Balakot air strikes        It's better to get hit early and hard: Kohli on bouncers        Messi 'made me better player', says Ronaldo        Nirav Modi to appear via videolink for remand hearing in UK        Rupee slips 17 paise to 71.72 vs USD in early trade        US seeking balancing act in South Asia over Kashmir: Report        Pro-growth RBI minutes to cap yields; revives expectations for further policy easing        N Korea dismisses nuclear talks if US 'hostile military moves' continue        
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | Health   | About Deepika 
National News
Karnataka crisis: Cong leaders speak in divergent voices on SC verdict
 
New Delhi: Congress leaders Wednesday spoke in divergent voices on the Supreme Court verdict in the Karnataka crisis, with chief spokesperson Randeep Surjewala saying it''s a "terrible precedent" but his colleague Abhishek Singhvi claiming victory. The Supreme Court said 15 rebel Congress-JD(S) MLAs in Karnataka "ought not" to be compelled to participate in the proceedings of the ongoing session of the Assembly, virtually sounding the death knell for the coalition government headed by H D Kumaraswamy.

The court at the same time gave Assembly Speaker K R Ramesh Kumar the freedom to decide on the resignation of the 15 MLAs within such time-frame as considered appropriate by him. Addressing the official press briefing, Congress spokesperson Abhishek Singhvi said the party has emerged victorious as 90 per cent of its arguments during the trial were accepted by the top court. "We are happy as a political party that we have emerged victorious," Singhvi, also a senior lawyer who appeared for the Karnataka Assembly Speaker in the case, told reporters outside Parliament.

"I welcome the Supreme Court to have given a decision as per the Constitution and law," he said accusing the BJP of "spreading misinformation and false propaganda". "Ninety per cent of the case argued says the speaker should decide in x number of days. Honourable court says we should not fetter the Speaker in any case. The SC has said the Speaker can decide what he likes, when he likes and hence the Speaker will decide. Where is the question of acting on a whip which has not been issued yet?" he asked. His colleague and the party''s chief spokesperson Randeep Surjewala, however, gave divergent views.

"SC''s order nullifying the whip & by extension, operation of Constitution''s Xth Schedule to punish MLAs betraying the public mandate, sets a terrible judicial precedent!" "Tragic that SC didn''t appreciate the context and designed history of defections to subvert democratic mandates by Modi Government over last 5 years. SC should recall own judgement of May 2016 striking down the illegal attempt of BJP in Uttarakhand to form government," Surjewala tweeted. "Blanket protection to MLAs, who are driven not by ideology but by far baser concerns, is unheard-of," he said.

He also wondered whether the verdict means the court can interfere with the working of the state legislature by deciding when a whip will be enforced and whether the basic structure doctrine of separation of powers had been abandoned. Singhvi separately said that on the basis of these petitions, the Speaker can accept or reject the resignation within his jurisdiction. "The decision will be entirely of the Speaker, in which the court refused to intervene." "If more people resign, the government should go, that''s how democracy works. There has been a misinformation campaign by the BJP in the last couple of weeks. Speaker will now be the master of the proceedings. He will decide as per his discretion," he said.

Singhvi said the false propaganda about the decision shows how the decision has gone against the opposition in Karnataka and claimed that claims of BJP leader Y S Yeddyurappa over government formation would remain "a dream". "I wonder which victory is Mr Yeddyurappa celebrating," he said. The Congress leader said the contention made by the Congress was that the court has no jurisdiction in the functioning of the legislature and the court has agreed to it. "The Court referred to Article 190 and Rule 202, which was our stand," he said. Singhvi said the court has specifically said that no fetters can be there on the Speaker and the direction is irrelevant to what the Speaker decides on the resignations as he will be the master of the proceedings in the house.

A bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi said the Karnataka Assembly Speaker''s discretion in deciding on the MLAs'' resignations should not be fettered by the court''s directions or observations and he should be left free to decide the issue. The Karnataka state unit of the Congress has termed the Supreme Court order as "bad judgment", which seemed to protect the defectors and encourage horse-trading. In a series of tweets, Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee (KPCC) president Dinesh Gundu Rao termed it an "extraordinary order". "Supreme Court order seems perfectly coordinated to help the rebel MLAs to violate the whip.

It has set a wrong precedent as the value of the Whip as per 10th schedule of the Constitution is now redundant. An extraordinary order indeed!!!," Rao tweeted. "The #SupremeCourt verdict is now encroaching upon the rights of the Legislature. This is a bad judgement which seems to protect the defectors and encourages horse trading and also violating the doctrine of separation of powers," he said in another tweet.


INX Media: SC grants interim protection to Chidambaram in ED case; no relief in CBI matter
Always said demonising Modi wrong: Singhvi
Alert in Tamil Nadu after intel of Lashkar terrorists' intrusion
FATF Asia-Pacific Group puts Pakistan in terror 'blacklist': Officials
Never met Peter or Indrani Mukherjea, says Karti Chidambaram, claims "political vendetta"
PM Modi begins three-nation trip, says engagements will strengthen India's relations with time-tested friends
No immediate plan to withdraw troops from J&K: Union Minister
HC gives Vadra four weeks to file rejoinder in plea to quash money laundering case
ED notice to MNS chief: Uddhav says doesn't expect concrete
Helicopter crashes in rain-hit Uttarkashi, three on board
No need for any debate on reservation: Paswan
Bengal's personalities write open letter to Mamata
Congress MLA Nirmala Gavit quits, may join Shiv Sena
Modi govt committed to development of northeast: Shah
Flood-like situation in parts of Punjab, Haryana, IAF rescues 9 people
Teachers report to schools in Kashmir, students don't
Yogi Adityanath to reshuffle UP cabinet on Monday
22 killed in rain-related incidents in HP
When night falls over the city, jawans on alert to keep Kashmir safe
Fire at AIIMS, 22 fire tenders rushed
ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
Vivek Oberoi to star in film on Balakot air strikes
 Mumbai: After portraying Prime Minister Narendra Modi in a biopic, Vivek Oberoi says he is set to pr  
Chris Pine to star in film about Richard Nixon lawyer John Dean
Amitabh Bachchan is my real life mentor: Chiranjeevi
It's challenging to reinvent constantly: Kriti Kharbanda
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
Despite tensions, Pak stands ready to open Kartarpur Corridor: Qureshi
 Islamabad: Pakistan on Friday said that despite tensions with India, it stands ready to open the Kar
Two Govt hospitals in Pak deny specialised ambulance facility to Sharif
UN, France raise concern over Amazon wildfires 'crisis'
US seeking balancing act in South Asia over Kashmir: Report
KERALA NEWS
Malayalam actor, film crew stranded in Himachal village
 Thiruvananthapuram: A 30-member film crew from Kerala, including award-winning actress Manju Warrier
Ex-Deputy Commandant of AR camp held in connection with constable's death
"More flights to Kerala from Gulf countries during Onam"
Flood in Kerala: CM conducts aerial survey
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2019 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.