12
Wednesday
May 2021
7:07 PM IST
News Headlines
Tour of Sri Lanka: Two-way fight for India captaincy between Hardik and Shikhar        India projected to grow at 10.1% in 2022 but outlook for 2021 highly fragile: UN        Rockets kill 2 Israelis; 28 die in Gaza as Israel hits Hamas        Delhi reports 12,481 Covid cases, 347 deaths        Kerala woman killed in Palestinian rocket strike in Israel        Kerala''s ''Iron Lady'' K R Gowri Amma no more        Virat Kohli, Ishant Sharma get first dose of vaccination        Sensex surges over 350 pts in early trade; Nifty tops 14,900        Israeli police, Palestinians clash at Jerusalem holy site        Had govt done its job, it would not have come to this: Rahul on foreign aid        Himanta Biswa Sarma sworn-in as 15th Chief Minister of Assam        Obesity and Bariatric Surgery        COVID-19 pandemic: Centre releases Rs 8923.8 cr to Panchayats in 25 states        BJP announces Dr Himanta Biswa Sarma as Assam Chief Minister        Debris from China''s disintegrating rocket falls into Indian Ocean        Kerala poet''s FB account ''suspended'' for posting satire clip on BJP poll defeat        TV journalist Vipin Chandh dies of COVID-19        Kerala adds 35,801 new COVID-19 cases, 68 more deaths        US Navy seizes weapons in Arabian Sea likely bound for Yemen        EU doesn''t renew order for AstraZeneca vaccine        
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | Health   | About Deepika 
Kerala News
COVID-19: SC says it can''t be mute spectator in national crisis, doesn''t intend to supplant HC
 
New Delhi: Terming the massive resurgence of COVID-19 cases a ''national crisis'', the Supreme Court Tuesday said it cannot remain a “mute spectator” and made clear that its suo motu proceeding on devising national policy for COVID-19 management is not meant to supplant high court hearings. A bench headed by Justice D Y Chandrachud said the high courts are in a better position to monitor the pandemic situation within their territorial boundaries and the apex court was playing a complementary role and its “intervention must be understood in the correct perspective” as there are some matters which transcend the regional boundaries. "There is a need for top court''s intervention on certain national issues as there might be matters related to coordination between states", it said, adding, “by the pendency of these proceedings, the High Courts are not restrained from continuing to deal with the issue that they are seized of".

"We are playing complementary role. If High Courts have any difficulty in dealing with issues due to territorial limitations, we will help,” said the bench, also comprising Justices L Nageswara Rao and S Ravindra Bhat. The bench clarified the purpose behind its “suo motu intervention” and said it was not to “supplant the high courts and not to take over the valuable role that they have taken under Article 226 of the constitution". “At the same time, it is also important for the Supreme Court to intervene to look into the systemic, national issues and ensure the coordination at a national level and between the states, which high courts may find difficult to deal with. This is a national crisis and the Supreme Court, being the national constitutional court, cannot be a silent spectator.”

These observations assume significance as some lawyers had criticized the apex court on April 22 for taking suo motu cognizance of the pandemic''s resurgence and issues by saying that high courts be allowed to continue with hearings. A day later on April 23, a bench headed by the then CJI S A Bobde, who has retired, took a very strong exception to “unfair” criticism by some lawyers for “something which was not part of its order” in the suo motu case and had said “this is how institution is being destroyed”. In the hearing conducted via video conferencing, it also asked the Centre to apprise the top court of the modalities on distribution of oxygen as well as the vaccines to states and the monitoring mechanism. It appointed senior advocates Jaideep Gupta and Meenakshi Arora as amicus curiae to assist it in the COVID-19 management case as senior counsel Harish Salve had sought recusal following some controversial remarks by some lawyers.

It also sought information on projected demand for oxygen in the country and the steps which are being taken to “augment the availability of oxygen”, putting in place the mechanism to monitor supply of oxygen to states. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta urged the bench not to seek information about total availability of oxygen in the country. "I have good reason for it. The oxygen is being augmented but I do not want to create any panic," the law officer said and the bench acceded to his plea. The law officer said the Centre does not oppose any constitutional courts if they seek any information on how the central government is dealing with this crisis. He said “as a nation, we are dealing with the unprecedented surge. The coordination between the states inter se is a matter which is being looked into from the highest political executive level, by both the Centre and the states.”

The bench asked the Centre to clarify the issue of enhancement of the critical medical infrastructure- number of beds, treatment centres equipped with personnel, healthcare professionals, besides seeking details about availability of drugs such as Remdesivir. The bench said that there was a need for a system of “seamless communication of their requirements from the district collectors to the Health Departments of the states to the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and for a daily monitoring of the same”. The bench on April 22 took note of the pandemic situation due to sudden surge in COVID-19 cases as also in mortality and said it expected the Centre to come out with a “national plan” to deal with distribution of essential services and supplies, including oxygen and drugs.

Observing that oxygen to patients infected with the virus is said to be an “essential part” of treatment, the top court had said it seemed that a certain amount of “panic” has been generated due to which people have approached several high courts seeking relief.


Kerala woman killed in Palestinian rocket strike in Israel
Kerala poet''s FB account ''suspended'' for posting satire clip on BJP poll defeat
TV journalist Vipin Chandh dies of COVID-19
Kerala adds 35,801 new COVID-19 cases, 68 more deaths
COVID-19: Kerala logs 41,971 cases, 64 deaths
Temples to remain shut during lockdown in Kerala
COVID spike : 13KL oxygen plant being set up at Kozhikode Medical College Hospital in Kerala
Funeral of Philipose Mar Chrysostom held with state honours
COVID-19: Kerala logs 42,464 cases, 63 deaths
Former head of Mar Thoma Church Dr Philipose Mar Chrysostom passes away
COVID-19:Kerala to strengthen anti-COVID measures, to deploy medical students to tackle situation
BJP loses lone seat in Kerala;'Metroman', state president fail
Lack of strong leadership in state led to UDF's downfall
Kerala CM requests people to use double masks
"Ensure no assembly of people in Kerala for 4 days from May 1 in connection with counting of votes"
Kerala mulling complete lockdown in dists with severe spread; 37,199 cases reported
Woman falls down from train, suffers injury, ornaments robbed
Kerala logs over 35,000 cases in highest single day surge, 41 deaths
No plans for lockdown now, but more restrictions to be put in place: CM
Ker logs over 32k new COVID cases in highest single day surge; CM says situation in state grim
ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
George Clooney says Capitol attack put Trump family 'into the dustbin of history'
 Los Angeles: Hollywood star George Clooney has condemned the attack on the Capitol Hill in the US by  
'Mean Girls' won't be returning to Broadway
Ian McKellan is 'happy' Elliot Page came out as transgender
A R Rahman thanks fans for support during 'difficult times'
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
Rockets kill 2 Israelis; 28 die in Gaza as Israel hits Hamas
 Gaza City: A confrontation between Israel and Hamas sparked by weeks of tensions in contested Jerusa
Israeli police, Palestinians clash at Jerusalem holy site
Debris from China''s disintegrating rocket falls into Indian Ocean
US Navy seizes weapons in Arabian Sea likely bound for Yemen
NATIONAL NEWS
Delhi reports 12,481 Covid cases, 347 deaths
 New Delhi: The national capital continues to register a dip in daily COVID-19 cases, as the city rec
Had govt done its job, it would not have come to this: Rahul on foreign aid
BJP announces Dr Himanta Biswa Sarma as Assam Chief Minister
Mumbai civic body is suppressing COVID-19 death toll: Fadnavis
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2021 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.